Claude Cheat Keys for UN Reporting & Briefing

Pre-submission QA on the Technical expert review of biennial transparency reports

I asked Claude, with the red-team-review skill, to run a pre-submission QA on FCCC/PA/CMA/2026/10. Its verdict was not ready to submit.

3 min read4 sectionsSources opened 2026-10-23.
Save this page.Every prompt below copies in one click. Dates are the editions quoted.Jump to the first prompt

The work moment

I was about to submit FCCC/PA/CMA/2026/10, Technical expert review of biennial transparency reports. I needed to know three things. Is every promised chapter and annex there? Do the percentages match the tables? Do the evaluative claims have evidence?

The summary promises this:

"Furthermore, the report presents challenges encountered by the secretariat , Parties and technical expert reviewers in conducting the reviews." [p 1]

The structure paragraph promises a chapter:

"IX below) and budgetary and financial matters (see chap. X below)." [p 3]

The text gives a share:

"Of the assignments, 280 (50.5 per cent) were allocated to GHG inventories" [p 9]

And a response rate:

"837 experts (64.0 per cent of those to whom the survey was sent) responded indicating their availability." [p 8]

What the test showed

Claude ran with the red-team-review skill. Tools allowed: WebFetch, Bash(curl:*). Asked 2026-10-30 23:45 UTC.

The verdict:

The stored copy stops mid-sentence and is missing three parts that the report itself promises.

On chapter X:

Para 4 promises chapter X and annexes I–II [p 3]. The text ends "(see para. 25 ab" [p 21].

On the GHG share:

280/554 = 50.54%, so the text is right and the table is wrong.

On the survey response rate:

Figure 4's last pair is "1 317" recipients and "837" respondents [p 8], and 837/1,317 = 63.6%.

On the expert count in Table 4:

But the text says "A total of 355 experts participated in TERs" [p 9], and 431 is the number of participations.

On evidence:

The figures also disagree with each other in four places, and about 15 claims have no evidence behind them.

The steps of the skill

These are the steps Claude followed in the test.

  1. Build a checklist. No checklist was supplied, so Claude built a 16-item checklist from standard UN documentation practice.
  2. Mark each item. PASS, FAIL or UNVERIFIED, each with a reason and a quote with its page marker.
  3. Check format and length. Where no limit was supplied, the length is marked UNVERIFIED.
  4. Recompute the figures. Every percentage and total is checked against the tables.
  5. List findings, most severe first. Each finding comes with a fix.
  6. List claims lacking supporting evidence. Each claim is quoted with what is missing.
  7. Say what checked out. Then give a score, the most serious flaw, the top recommendation and what it is least confident about.

Copy-paste prompt

Paste into Claude
Please run a pre-submission QA on the attached secretariat report on the technical expert review of biennial transparency reports, which is attached below. Check it against a submission checklist and mark each item as passed or failed with a reason, confirm the format and length constraints, and list any claim that lacks supporting evidence. Quote the document word for word with its page marker, such as [p 3], for every quote you use.

Sources