The work moment
A progress report is due. The results framework calls some lines outcomes, but the team can deliver some of them alone. A workshop held is in the team's control. What participants do afterwards is not.
JIU/REP/2017/6 names this pattern ([p 12], Summary of challenges):
- Focusing on outputs that are within one ’s control and achievable and , at times , identifying those as outcomes, given the nature of the accountability system, as well as fear of being found to be unsuccessful when outcomes are not achieved;
The same report names the pressure to report on outcomes ([p 33], para 47(c)):
- Disconnect between the longer-term outcome requirements of results-based management and the reporting cycle, with pressure to report on outcomes no matter the situation;
An output with an outcome label makes a report claim a change that nobody has shown.
What the test showed
I asked Claude about a made-up extract from a youth employment project with three outcome lines. Both runs had the same tools and were asked on 2026-10-30. Both called A and B outputs and C a real outcome. The differences are below.
Targets. Without the skill:
You could make it measurable, e.g. "% of graduates in paid work for at least 6 months, within 12 months of finishing training."
With the skill:
I haven't added targets, baselines or dates because the extract has none.
Actors. Without the skill:
or, one level up, "Students in partner schools make better-informed career choices."
With the skill:
Both use only actors your extract already names: young people, schools and partner districts.
Why it happens. Without the skill, the answer gave no source. With the skill:
Why it happens (JIU/REP/2017/6, page xii, "Summary of challenges", item (b)): "Focusing on outputs that are within one's control and achievable and, at times, identifying those as outcomes, given the nature of the accountability system, as well as fear of being found to be unsuccessful when outcomes are not achieved;"
Reporting pressure. Without the skill:
Calling outcomes achieved without evidence is a risk that a donor review or evaluation is likely to catch.
With the skill:
On reporting every outcome as achieved this cycle, the same report names that pressure (paragraph 47, page 17, item (c)): "Disconnect between the longer-term outcome requirements of results-based management and the reporting cycle, with pressure to report on outcomes no matter the situation;"
Evidence for C. Without the skill:
C usually can't be shown within one cycle because retention takes time to observe.
With the skill:
Not covered: the extract doesn't show what evidence you have for C this cycle, so I can't say whether it has been achieved.
Test used. Only the answer with the skill said which test it used:
Test used: the control question (the extract does not define output or outcome)
The steps of the skill
The skill is called logframe-qa. It has 7 steps.
- Open the report. Copy its title and document symbol from the cover. Find both passages and check they read as quoted. If the PDF does not open, record
REPORT NOT OPENEDand go on. - Read your document. If it defines output and outcome, use those definitions in place of the control question, and say so.
- List the outcome lines. Keep the exact words. If the document has no labels, ask which lines are meant as outcomes.
- Ask the control question. Could the team finish all of its own work and this line still not be true? If yes, it reads as an outcome. If no, it reads as an output.
- Mark what is unclear. If the document does not say who has to change, or what the team delivers, mark the line
UNCLEARand name the missing piece. - Rewrite. For each output labelled as an outcome, name the change it should lead to. Use an actor the document already names, or write
ACTOR NOT IN DOCUMENT. Keep the original line as an output. - Add the background. If the report opened, add the first passage. Add the second only when the user mentions pressure to report outcomes every cycle.
The skill never adds a target, baseline, indicator value or date that the document does not contain. It does not judge the project or the team. The check is about labels only.
Copy-paste prompt
Check the results framework I paste below. For every line labelled as an outcome, tell me if it reads as an outcome or as an output. Use this question. Could my team finish all of its own work and this line still not be true? If yes, it is an outcome. If no, my team controls it and it is an output. If my document defines output and outcome, use those definitions instead. Quote each line as I wrote it and give your verdict with a short reason. Write UNCLEAR where my document does not say enough. For each output labelled as an outcome, suggest a rewrite that names who should change, using only actors named in my document. For background, use only the Joint Inspection Unit report at https://www.unjiu.org/sites/www.unjiu.org/files/jiu_rep_2017_6_english__0.pdf and quote it word for word. If you cannot open it, say so and do not fill from memory. Do not add targets or dates that are not in my document.
Before you paste
Use your own working notes, leave out anything marked confidential, and use the AI tool your organization allows.