The work moment
I had to brief my supervisor on the technical expert review of biennial transparency reports before CMA 8. The source is FCCC/PA/CMA/2026/10 · Technical expert review of biennial transparency reports. It is long, and my copy has broken spacing in places.
What the report says about expert supply:
"The continued limited availability of qualified experts and the high rate of rejection from experts, particularly those not eligible for funding by the secretariat to participate in TERs, combined with the competing priorities of invited experts, placed growing pressure on the timely organization and delivery of TERs." [p 18]
"a potential future shortage of experts for those thematic areas and could necessitate more nominations of qualified experts to ensure adequate thematic coverage in TERTs." [p 7]
And what the garbled text looks like. The page header runs into the sentence:
"FCCC/PA/CMA/2026/10 9 were changes in work commitments since responding to the availability survey (50.6 per cent) and lack of financial support (27.2 per cent)." [p 9]
What the test showed
I ran the prompt with the brief skill on 2026-10-30 at 22:13 UTC. Tools allowed: WebFetch, Bash(curl:*). The answer quoted 8 lines from the report word for word, each with its page marker.
The claim block:
Reviews are being completed at a record pace, but the supply of reviewers is now the limit. Status: At risk.
The ask quoted the lead reviewers:
do we support the lead reviewers' call for "expanding the use of the centralized group review format for the LDCs and SIDS" [p 19]?
It named a gap:
Gap: there are no budget figures here because the copy provided stops at p 21, before chapter X (budget).
It kept the garbled text out of its quotes:
Quotes avoid the garbled text. The copy has broken spacing in places (for example "1 36 Parties" on p 3 and "12 4 Parties" on p 5). I only quoted clean passages and cited those numbers without quoting them. Check them against the official PDF before circulating.
And it said which part was its own:
The ask is my framing. The report doesn't say what your team decides, so I assumed you need a position for CMA 8.
The steps
These are the steps the test answer followed.
- Put the brief skill in your Project. Paste the prompt and attach the report below it.
- Claim. One line with a status word: On track, At risk or Blocked.
- Evidence. Every figure gets its source and year. Every quote is word for word with its page marker.
- Ask. One decision with options and a recommended one.
- Checks. Read the list at the end before you send. Fill in the placeholders. Check any garbled numbers against the official PDF.
Copy-paste prompt
Please write an internal one-pager on the status of the technical expert review of biennial transparency reports for my supervisor, using the secretariat report attached below. Organize it into three blocks labeled claim, evidence and ask, give every figure its source and year, and keep it to one page. Quote the document word for word with the page marker for every quote you use.